Forgive – Or Don’t Forgive – Your Rapist

TW, CW: Discussion of rape.

When I was eighteen, I fell in love with a man, or at least, I thought I did. Nearly five years my senior, and a foot and an inch taller than I, he was the epitome of sexy: a long-armed, blonde-haired drummer who had all the right words to say to a little lonely girl. Fresh out of high school with my first pink razor flip phone, I was intent on finding myself, cutting my hair short, buying my first ringtone (Grace Kelly, by Mika), and travelling by Greyhound hither and thither and yon in search of some missing part of me. He was a roadie touring with the Wailers (of Bob Marley & fame), something of a womanizer, and for one night only, in Tacoma, Washington, before going overseas.

Tacoma, Washington
Tacoma, Washington

Perhaps you can imagine how it went. I showed up on the bus, alone, wearing American Eagle jeans and a green hoodie, my hair unwashed, having spent the previous two evenings in a Seattle hostel. He picked me up and spun me around – had a man ever been so pleased to see me? – bought and poured Coke and rum into a plastic cup. We sat backstage at the show. He was in and out, attending to water bottles, towels, straightening wires and running a clean set. The band members admired my beauty. One touched my breasts, even as I fell backwards, my little 5’2 frame not used to drinking, and intoxicated. “Matt’s gonna have fun with you tonight,” the band member told me.

In what exists of my memory of that night, Matt did have fun with me. This I recall with great certainty – the look of his eyes, squinting with laughter as he smiled down at me. My confusion was total. The next day I awoke with my clothes folded neatly on a chair. I remember the exact order: jeans, sweater, little violet shirt. Panties, socks, bra, my bracelets stacked atop the pile. Did Matt do this, or did a hotel attendant take such care with my clothes? I may never know. I heard the shower faucet dripping, but I was completely alone. I never asked him if he folded my clothes. He left so entirely, with not even a text message on my pink flip-phone to say goodbye, nor $20 for a cab, or a word of advice: whether we’d had sex or hadn’t. And I couldn’t remember.


A sign in a women’s shelter, found on

For Native American women, rape is a fact of life. It is as real as frybread or fancydancing. The bruises Matt left on my collarbone, around my throat, are veritable accessories in Indian Country, where 88% of assaults committed against Native women come from Caucasian men, who are transient, in and out of their lives. One in three Native women either have or will experience rape, more than twice the national average, but in some parts of the United States and Canada, the rate is much higher, as much as twelve times the national average. Up until very recently (signed in 2013 but in effect as of 2015), with the Violence Against Women act being passed with increased protection for Indigenous women, tribal governments could do little to nothing to prosecute men who abused their women. Even if they were able to be prosecuted, Indian Health Services’ care clinics often did not have rape kits or other resources the VAWA has now made standard and mandatory. The funding and support the VAWA will provide Indigenous women is the most important piece, in my mind, of the Obama Administration’s work. He may never be recognized widely for all he’s done for Indigenous women, but in my mind, President Obama deserves his Nobel Peace Prize.


When I think of one in three Native American women experiencing rape or attempted rape, I consider the fact that I have two sisters. From very early on, from the first memories returning of that night in Tacoma, that hotel, and that trauma, I thought of my sisters, who were nine and eight at the time. Some logical fallacy in my mind told me that it would all be worth it if I was the one in three, and they were no longer at risk. I began to believe that they would not – could not – be hurt, because I already had been. Of course, such magical thinking does no good, and I know that my past pain can serve as no guarantee of their safety. Yet if there was one thing I could protect them from, this would be it.

Now I know that not everything happens for a reason, that you don’t have to ascribe meaning to the things that devastate you. Some things happen because human beings can be complete garbage cans. But try convincing me of that when I was green out of high school.

I was young, then, though it was only eight years ago, and I didn’t know how anything worked. When the memories began to surface, three months after the assault, I was blighted with the symptoms of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. I became very neutorotic and unwell. I listened to the same song over and over, repeating the words and hugging myself. I could sleep only in the early hours of the morning, after the sun had come up. I began to see Matt’s face in everyone else’s, even as he was ten-thousand miles away. Oh, and I was sad: overwhelmingly, agonizingly sad. It was a knife that cut so deep, I was scarred with hot white blindness. I walked, in the rain, in the night, in the traffic, listening to Regina Spektor – oh, they build buildings so tall, these days. I took no care to oncoming traffic. It’s a wonder I was not struck by a car.

The pain was made all the more total and absolute by the fact that I missed Matt, missed him with my whole being. I wanted to be near him, to be with him, to speak to him, to be loved by him.

How do you hate someone you are still so in love with?


One of the turning points for me came when I heard the song Chicago by Sufjan Stevens.

I was in love with a place/In my mind/In my mind

I made a lot of mistakes/In my mind/In my mind

The constant but beautiful refrain, “I made a lot of mistakes” provided me with the necessary comfort to begin getting on with life. But I didn’t fully get on, not really, not for years. I was plagued by the pain of those memories for half a decade. I would remember with sharp, bitter stabs.  Formerly boy-crazy, when on dates, even with really good men, I would be overwhelmed by feelings of shame and discomfort, a heaviness in the car around me, a fear, and a longing for home. I was unable to obtain the intimacy and even friendship I desired because of the shame I felt.

But how could I be ashamed, when I wasn’t the one who did anything?

I continued to try to understand. I stalked Matt’s Myspace, watched his top 8 friends, viewed his pictures and photo comments. I wanted to ask him, Is it because I’m beautiful? Did you do this to me because I’m beautiful? 

I did not know then what I know now: that rape is not about sex, that rape is not about my beauty or my body. It was not about my partner loving or even desiring me. Rape is about power. Rape is about a person choosing to remove their partner’s bodily autonomy. Rape is saying, my current desire to have power over your body is more important than obtaining freely given, ongoing, enthusiastic consent.

When I was young, I didn’t know that. I grew up religious, and I don’t remember being talked to about consent. Sex was something sacred, to be reserved for marriage. My body was meant to be “the greatest gift I would give my husband.” Sex outside of marriage wasn’t something anyone considered an option in the circles I ran in. Since childhood, I’d learned about purity, but I never learned about consent. Why wouldn’t I want to be with my husband?

Now I know that there was nothing I could have done to prevent my rape from happening. It was as inevitable as the moon following the sun, because Matt made the decision to rape me and methodically navigaged a path to making it happen. As soon as he had made the choice, it was set in stone, because that’s what he took from me: the ability to have a choice.

I was so sad and so afraid for so long that I’d lost something intrinsic, something I’d been “saving” for a husband. But in truth, I never lost anything, because I never gave him anything. He did not take my dignity. He did not take my honor. He did not take my kindness, my passion, or my purity. He did not take my truth.

What he took from me was my consent.

Although Sufjan Stevens’ “Chicago” provided me with comfort, I didn’t make “a lot of mistakes.” I didn’t make a single mistake. Even my sadness, my trauma, and my shame were not mistakes. They were simply my feelings that I had to experience before I could feel whole again.

The path to being well was, and has been long. What I can tell any survivor living out their truth, in all its pain, is this: It was not your fault. It was not your fault. It was not your fault. It was not your fault. There’s nothing wrong with you; there’s nothing you did wrong. You are good enough. You are precious. You are important and you matter. You deserve to be loved. Most of all, you deserve the right to consent.

At the end of the day, the choice to forgive or not to forgive is yours, and no one can make it but you. It is your right to decide. In the end, I decided to forgive Matt. Not because I remembered that he used to call me Sweet Pea. Not because he picked me up and spun me around when he first saw me that day. Not even because of the exhausted, lonely way his eyes went when he thought you didn’t see. I chose to forgive him for me. Because this was my act of taking back autonomy. I made a choice only I could make because I was the only one who could make it.

I may not yet be entirely well. I may not be the person I was before I was raped, and perhaps I never will be. I can never know who that person would have been. I know who I am now. I know that I can consider my soul, and I know that it is well.


22 thoughts on “Forgive – Or Don’t Forgive – Your Rapist

      1. Thank you for sharing. It’s been my experience that these things never really leave you, but it is good that you have taken control of your pain and found your strength. I know how difficult it must have been to write this. You are a very strong woman.

      1. tbh: I never did get back to feeling well I was traumatized I was only 7 at the time an memories well come back and it scares me to this day I can’t trust no man im very secure of myself an surroundings when something like that happens it will never go away but in time I learned to forgive but never to trust a man but to answer your question I never felt okay I still feel scared even if it happen long ago even if I forget it something or someone will bring it up an it will all come back to my mind the fear an pain.

  1. I agree with queenupliftyou, forgiveness is definitely for you and not the other person. I think it’s extremely brave of you to share your experience, traumatic as it must have been with the online community of followers you now have. Thank you for sharing and I’ll be praying for your continued healing.

  2. I had to forgive. It cost me a baby and 5 years of regret. He was my best friend. My boyfriend. The person I told all my secrets and even when I said no he made me feel like it was my job to fix him, when he was the one breaking me. At one point I wanted to kill him, but the anger and bitterness just made me weak while he went about living his life. Love you!

  3. I am very sorry this happened to you. I was assaulted by an ex too, I chose to forget and more importantly, I chose to, a very deliberate mental exercise on my part to purge the shame, guilt and blame from my system. It was hard, but it was only when I was successful doing that, I was was truly free. Now I look back on it, it was like it happened to another person. It was not me he assaulted, it was a weaker version of me, that person no longer exists.
    This blog is also informing me of Native American issues that I was unaware of until now. So, thank you. The struggles of all minorities deserve to be heard. And coincidentally, I wrote about rape and our sick rape culture recently too:

  4. I applaud your freedom from shame in writing about this.
    I have been close to two people who have been raped; my father and my (now-estranged) wife. (I am a bit puzzled why there has to be a euphemism when it happens to children. They were both raped as children. So was my sister in law). I have never been raped; I don’t want to come across as disrespectful. I know I don’t know what I am talking about here. I have, however, been affected by what I will call ‘unconscious abuse of the word forgiveness’. I have seen it become something of a stumbling block for a couple of people, wherein they simply didn’t/wouldn’t/couldn’t (yet), process what had happened to them. ‘Process’ is such a cold word, for something so emotional and deep and difficult, I don’t know. I have to believe the past can be repaired somehow, in life, and by life.
    May everyone become free of these shadows, by all means necessary, is what I want to say, and thanks, for helping that happen.

  5. As well as for sharing such a deeply personal and difficult story, I would like to thank you for introducing me to such beautiful music. That song by Sufjan Stevens does sound very healing.

  6. Only weak men raped women. Its not a question of being a female but about dysfunctionality of men who think they must have access to the other sex without their consent.

    What of men that are raped too. I know society will make us believe its rare compare to women. Talking from a 15 years old boy being raped by his aunt for good 6 years.

    Forgiveness is about you, hate in your heart will consume you too. You gotta let go and let God. Get all the support you can get though

  7. Only weak men raped women. Its not a question of being a female but about dysfunctionality of men who think they must have access to the other sex without their consent.

    What of men that are raped too. I know society will make us believe its rare compare to women. Talking from a 15 years old boy being raped by his aunt for good 6 years.

    Forgiveness is about you, hate in your heart will consume you too. You gotta let go and let God. Get all the support you can get though

  8. I think for me, forgiveness or acceptance is a process. I tried to trick myself into forgiving by saying I forgave an ex, but I really hadn’t. I think embracing the pain, anger, bitterness, etc, and allowing it to go through the process helped me. Resisting against it, isn’t healthy, but kinda just accepting that “negative emotions” aren’t really negative at all but are just telling me something bad happened. Feel the emotions, but control the actions is what I tell myself.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s